Condominiums vs. Cooperatives
What is the difference?
You might look at two similar buildings and think that they are
both condominiums (condos), where in fact, one may be a cooperative
(co-op). The question remains: "What is the difference?"
Both are common forms of living, much like apartment building
living. In New York City, there are some co-op buildings with
extremely luxurious apartments on Central Park. In Canada, most
co-op buildings are affordably priced and tend to be geared towards
lower cost living. As well, the vast majority of co-ops in Ontario
tend to be non-profit. This discussion will not focus on the non-profit
segment, but rather exclusively on equity co-ops with share capital.
The goal of this article is to provide some practical information
regarding some of the differences between the two, and does not
claim to be an exhaustive discussion. Your lawyer can advise you
more fully on other differences.
One of the greatest advantages of condominium living is the maintenance
free aspect of home ownership. One can quite simply turn the key
to lock the door and leave all of the outside work to be done
for you - exterior painting, gardening, snow removal, etc. This
is often not the case with co-op living.
Co-op is the short form or root of the term "cooperative". You
may also think of it in another way - "co-operation". Every resident
cooperates and chips in to do the work at the building. Since
there are fewer services hired out to external service providers,
the monthly fees are also lower. John Smith may be in charge of
the bookkeeping, Jane Doe may be in charge of all gardening, David
Jones may be responsible for hallway cleaning, etc. These duties
may change every month.
From a legal perspective the difference is quite simple. Much
like a house or a car, you as a purchaser, obtain precise title
(or "deed") to a specific condo unit. You are in essence buying
space in the air (apartment condos), but that space is spelled
out in detail. If you bought unit #1005 for example, the legal
description may read as "Wentworth Condominium Corporation 123,
Level 10, Unit 05, and locker #1, and parking space #1). As you
can see, it is quite clear what unit you own. In addition to that
specific space, you also own a proportionate amount of space of
the common elements (hallways, front foyer, basement, outside
green space, etc.). If there are 100 units in the condo building,
there are 100 individual titles. The governing body over the condo
is indeed a corporation, but without share capital. Given that
you have specific title to a property, you can arrange for a standard
conventional or high ratio mortgage through any mortgage company
or bank.
This is precisely the issue that prevents many people from buying
a unit in a cooperative - financial institutions will not give
a mortgage for a co-op. There is only ONE title over the entire
building and the co-op owners hold shares in the co-op corporation,
with the right to occupy in a defined unit. Even if there are
100 units in the co-op building, there still is only one title
over the entire property. Co-op owners must purchase their unit
in cash, since they do not have a specific title to hypothecate
(i.e. pledge as security).
Regarding the purchase of a condo, you do not require any approval
from any of the residents. On the other hand, you may be restricted
from purchasing a co-op. The board of the co-op (comprised of
the residents) must approve you as a purchaser. The board wants
to ensure that you "fit in" with the other residents. Yes, indeed,
this is completely legal. They also want to ensure that you have
the financial means to pay your monthly fees and the physical
ability to complete the required work.
Also, please keep in mind that there may be additional restrictions
governing the use of a co-op. For example, most co-ops will not
allow you to rent out your unit.
When you are purchasing a home, you want to make an informed decision.
There are several other aspects you will wish to know before putting
in an offer on a condo or co-op:
1. If it is an older building, are there substantial funds in the
reserve to cover upcoming repairs and maintenance? For example,
when the roof needs to be replaced.
2. If it is an older building, has the building recently been retrofitted
to meet the new fire code?
3. With a condo, make your offer conditional upon the receipt and
review of an estoppel certificate - the estoppel certificate is
prepared by the property manager and will show the balance in
the reserve fund, whether there is any litigation against the
building, whether the monthly fees on your unit are in arrears,
etc. You will need to specifically ask these questions to the
board of a co-op since estoppel certificates aren't prepared by
co-ops.
4. Find out whether there have been any outstanding special assessments
levied against the owner's unit?
5. What do the monthly fees include? What obligations are there
upon the residences in a co-op?
I hope that this discussion sheds some light on some of the differences
between these two types of ownership. Please contact me if I can
be of any further assistance to you in the Hamilton-Burlington
region.
* not intended to solicit properties currently listed for sale |